the effect of containerization on shenzhen and hong kong (and coffee beans)

I’ve been trying to map the emergence of the Pacific Rim from the perspective of Shenzhen. It’s an easy rabbit hole to fall into: neolithic navigation (from Peninsular Southeast Asia to littoral South China), the Austronesian diaspora, trade links between the South China Sea and Indian Ocean, the emergence of Quanzhou as Asia’s most important port, colonial incursions, the discovery of silver in Mexico and the establishment of the Acapulco-Manila silver route, piracy and privateers, and then containerization…so many rabbit holes!

A local magazine asked me to write an essay on the containerization part of the story, so I did. However, the editorial board kicked it back as being “too academic.” In the meantime, I’m uploading that essay and working on something more “popular.” Also, the essay focuses on trade, rather than militarization. I’m trying to get that timetable in order and braid it into the container trade story… If you have thoughts and/or insights please reach out — the topic is vast and fascinating and needs dialogue to refine.

interview with caixin new media vice president zhou zhichen

Last week’s interview with 财新新传媒副总周智琛 is now up on the Caixin website as part of their 龙中对 series of interviews. “为城市立心” is about 35 minutes (no commercials) and gives a good sense of how the public debate on urban villages is now being framed, or more accurately how I’m now framing the conversation in terms of my own sojourn. To view the interview, ether use the VR code in the poster or follow this link.

langkou homecoming

A bit of housekeeping. In “Langkou Homecoming: Art Sprouts, the P+V Gallery and Future Shenzheners,” Zhang Kaiqin and I reflect on our practice at Qianzhen Girls’ School, 2016-2018. The Chinese citation is “乐把他乡变故乡——“艺术童萌”与虔贞⼥校艺展馆的未来深圳⼈”, 发表于《鹤湖⽂史辑刊》(第⼀辑),⽂物出版社,2022年11⽉。

wtf huanggang?

These past few days we’ve been “eating melons,”–the colloquial expression for watching other people’s drama. This time, its an internecine melodrama starring the Shuiwei and Huanggang Zhuangs.

Continue reading

shake hands with 302

More publicity about Handshake 302.

where in shenzhen is mary ann odonnell?

Today, I’m in an English language reader for Chinese elementary and middle school students! I’m in the People Power section along with Zou Hongtao (who came to Shenzhen in 1979 with the Corps of Civil Engineering) and Frank Wang Tao (汪滔), the founder of DJI. It’s true, China’s Foreign Language and Teaching Press is putting out a series of graded readers for young students and I’m in the Shenzhen book, City of Miracles.

a path out of shenzhen…

In 2023, we said, “Let’s see what happens after COVID.”

By April 2024, we were asking, “Where are you headed?”

Continue reading

what’s on display and who can see it?

This past week, in addition to participating in large public culture events, I also had the opportunity to visit two privately organized cultural spaces. The first was a private collection of shoushan stone carvings (寿山石) and the second was a community museum.

So some preliminary thoughts about what these spaces suggest about post COVID culture in Shenzhen.

Continue reading

material and spiritual traditions. thoughts?

Long ago and far away, I wondered when History would enter Shenzhen’s bildungsroman. And now that it has, it’s interesting to see how deeper settlements have emerged as roots for contemporary Shenzheners. The original SEZ–now the inner districts (关内)–especially Luohu (Dongmen) has become the city’s connection to Hong Kong. Indeed, it is still where you go if you want to speak Hong Kong Cantonese and eat delicious Cantonese and Chao-Shan style foods. In the outer districts, “Longgang” (and I’m using it in its circa 1990 designation, rather than picking through the new districts) is home to Hakka traditions, which are housed in the area’s great compounds (围屋、世居). In Bao’an (and yes, as a cultural homeland, we’re talking about the sliver of villages that stretch north-south between the reclaimed west coast (now Qianhai) and Bao’an Boulevard), ancestral halls are flourishing and traditions like lion dancing have been elevated to national immaterial culture status (上川黄连胜星狮舞). The Huang alliance comprises eight troups, extending from Shanghe to Fuyong.

What I’ve noticed is that this geographic distribution assumes different historical subjects which are all mushed together into some kind of “Shenzhen” identity. The implicit subject of history in Luohu, for example, are the cross-border entrepreneurs (个体户 mainly from Chao-Shan area) and their Hong Kong clientele (many who also originally hail from Chao-Shan). This first generation came in the early 1980s and transformed the old market into a gritty cross-border playground a la Tijuana. In Bao’an, the villages (now communities under a street office) have cultivated and paid for the continuation of their traditions, including pencai (盆菜) banquets, the birthdays of divinities and founding fathers, and celebrations at various scale. In contrast, in the Hakka areas, various levels of government have assumed responsibility for the compounds and are using them to promote new kinds of high culture. Pingshan Art Musuem, for example, includes the Dawan Compound (大万世居) as a satellite exhibition hall, while Longgang District has transformed the Hehu Compound (鹤湖新居) into the base of its cultural think tank, hosting outdoor lectures underneath shade trees.

So, thoughts du jour are more random associations that still make a kind of sense. Shenzhen’s culture and history are being reworked in ways that both deploy local cultural geographies and map along the city’s historic interest in establishing a new material and spiritual culture. In Luohu, the early Special Zone is re-emerging in new forms of (admittedly cleaned up) cross-border consumption; Bao’an is emerging as the locus of South China Sea diaspora connections (the lion dance, for example, is a major competition in the region), and Longgang compounds form a material platform for high end civilization, where the city’s “new guests” can strut their cultural stuff.

shenzhen’s population, circa october 2022

What is the population of Shenzhen? This question remains tough to answer because there is the official hukou population, the official long-term population, and the population of everyone who lives here or is here… Anyway, according to the Shenzhen Statistics bureau website, in 2022 the city’s population was 17.66 million. However, according to journalist Nan Zhaoxu, who does wonderful work ferretting out those bureaucratic nooks and crannies where alternative truths might be found, on Jan 1, 2022, the city processed 22.19 million covid swabs, making the difference between the official and resident populations about 4.5 million souls. Long story short: Since the mid 2010s, I have thought of the city as home to 20 million people. I am now bumping that figure up to 22 million.

This may mean that ways of counting people are finally catching up to the city’s actual number of residents because both population turnover and growth seem to have significantly slowed. However, it may also be the case that different bureaus have different forms of legitimacy as well as quite different relationships to the city. Public health, for example, was tasked to test everyone in the city. In contrast, education bureaus are only responsible to official youth. In this sense, the city’s “population” is the result of bureaucratic actions (such as registering people), rather than a group that exists as such.